Oil Price May Be Far Higher Than $100 Due to Market Mispricing

Oil Market Alert: Physical Scarcity Outpacing Benchmark Futures Prices

A widening gap between physical crude prices and benchmark futures is signaling that oil markets may be underestimating the scale of the ongoing supply shock and the potential for violent repricing. Morgan Stanley notes that near-term supply tightness has surged to extreme levels, while Macquarie warns that crude markets remain "too sanguine" about supply risks.

Physical Scarcity Far More Acute Than Headline Prices Suggest

Physical cargoes into Asia are trading at $130 to $170 per barrel, while refined products such as jet fuel are surging past $220. This divergence is partly due to earlier distortions fading, including discounted Russian crude that kept global benchmarks artificially contained. As that cushion disappears, the rest of the energy complex is likely to catch up.

Read also: Treasury Yields Experience Largest Increase in Two Weeks Following Release of Labor Market Data

Risk of Abrupt Price Discovery

Macquarie notes that once spare capacity and inventory cushions are drawn down, oil markets tend to shift from gradual adjustment to abrupt price discovery. Shortages "emerge slowly, then all at once," leaving little time for demand to respond. This could lead to a "molecular contagion" moving intercontinentally, compressing price spreads, and eroding buffers.

Supply Constrained, Demand Remains Intact

At the core of the argument is a simple imbalance: supply is constrained, demand remains intact, and inventories are being drawn down. To bring demand and supply back in line, prices will need to be far higher than current levels. Carlyle's Jeff Currie warns that policy tools offer limited relief when the constraint is availability, not liquidity.

Read also: US-Iran Tensions Spark Uptick in Oil Prices Amid Global Market Decline

Potential for Sharp Moves in Oil Prices

Even Charles Myers of Signum Global Advisors suggests that such crises often intensify before they ease, hinting that de-escalation requires a more forceful and coordinated response. Jonathan Wilmot of Aletheia Capital flags a narrow window to avoid further escalation, warning that failure to reopen the Strait of Hormuz could push oil towards $150 or higher.

Potential Impact on India

For India, the implications are more nuanced. Prashant Jain of 3P Investment Managers notes that the impact would depend on "how high crude oil goes and how long it stays at elevated levels." UBS estimates that a sustained move to $100 per barrel could shave 30 to 40 basis points off India's GDP growth, widen the current account deficit, and push inflation above the RBI's comfort band.

Cascading Effects Across the Real Economy

Carlyle's Jeff Currie warns of cascading effects across the real economy, including energy shortages feeding into fertilisers, agriculture, and industrial inputs. This could lead to a longer-term bull cycle in oil prices, with Shankar Sharma predicting prices could stretch to $150 to $200 if geopolitical tensions persist.