Comparing the Efficacy of Old and New Tax Regimes for Individuals Earning Rs 50 Lakhs

Tax Regime Choice for High-Income Earners Becomes Increasingly Complex

For individuals earning above Rs 50 lakh annually, choosing between the old and new tax regimes is no longer a straightforward decision. While the new regime offers lower tax slabs and a simplified structure, the old regime can still deliver better tax efficiency for those who are able to maximise deductions such as HRA, NPS contributions, medical insurance, and other exemptions.

Tax Liability Comparison

A recent analysis highlights how tax liability looks for income above Rs 50 lakh. The calculation assumes a gross annual salary of Rs 50 lakh from all employers, along with tax-free benefits including a leased car benefit worth Rs 5 lakh and fuel & driver reimbursement, along with meal card benefits worth Rs 1.05 lakh. This takes the total cost-to-company (CTC) to Rs 56.05 lakh.

Read also: Treasury Yields Experience Largest Increase in Two Weeks Following Release of Labor Market Data

Under the old tax regime, the employee is able to claim several deductions and exemptions that substantially reduce taxable income. These include the standard deduction of Rs 50,000, Section 80C deduction of Rs 1.5 lakh, Section 80D medical insurance deduction of Rs 25,000, employer contribution to NPS of Rs 2.5 lakh, additional employee contribution to NPS of Rs 50,000, along with HRA, LTA, and other allowances amounting to Rs 7 lakh.

In comparison, the new tax regime allows only limited deductions. The employee gets a standard deduction of Rs 75,000 and employer contribution to NPS of Rs 3.5 lakh. However, exemptions such as HRA, LTA, Section 80C, and medical insurance deductions are not available under the new regime.

Tax Benefit Variations

Read also: US-Iran Tensions Spark Uptick in Oil Prices Amid Global Market Decline

The tax benefit varies depending on whether the taxpayer has opted for the old or the new tax regime. Under the new tax regime, the employer's contribution is deductible up to 14 per cent of salary. In the old regime, the limit for private-sector employees is restricted to 10 per cent of salary, while Central and State government employees are permitted to claim a deduction of up to 14 per cent under both regimes.

Tax Liability Difference

The total tax liability, including education cess, works out to Rs 10.12 lakh under the old tax regime, compared to Rs 10.20 lakh under the new tax regime. This means the old tax regime still results in a tax saving of nearly Rs 7,800 for a salaried individual earning above Rs 50 lakh annually in this scenario.